Almost two years ago, I launched (what became) my 2012 book archive. There’s a bit of background on that project on that page. While there have been a few minor developments since then, none of them have been noteworthy enough to document here. Recently, however, I decided that I would try to make PDF copies of the books. I wanted these to be good-quality PDFs, as although a number of PDFs of the books had circulated from other groups in the past, they weren’t particularly visually appealing: they were essentially what you would get by quickly printing each of the HTML files from the publisher.
My guess was that a simple HTML file with all of the book content could be combined with a quick print CSS style and get good-quality output without too much effort. I figured that with a decent number of iterations on the book CSS and test runs, the project might take a week or so. Over two months later, I’m finally set to release the PDFs. I’ve made a few notes of the things that I did along the way, in case anybody finds them useful in the future.
If you just want the PDFs, you can visit the 2012 book archive and download them there. There are a few ways to download each book: you can download a whole-book PDF file, or a PDF for each chapter. Both are accessible from a book’s table of contents, and the whole-book PDFs can be downloaded from the archive’s book list as well.
Getting a PDF
It’s worth noting that the content I have from the books is already in an HTML format, not necessarily the raw input to a book creator. I decided early on to try to work with HTML and CSS, because although the HTML I have is structured and could probably be parsed into a different format, doing that correctly for over a hundred books would be iffy. With that said, the HTML was well-structured, and lent itself to easy use of CSS to style specific things.
If you’ve been following CSS development, there are a lot of features in CSS that are supposed to allow styling of printed content. Unfortunately, support for some of these in browsers is spotty, and they don’t necessarily provide all of the features that you’d like when styling a book. (In particular, footnotes, page-relative positioning, page numbering, and PDF bookmarks are all difficult. There are likely other features I’ve forgotten about as well.)
At first, I was hoping to be able to use something like wkhtmltopdf, which wraps WebKit and converts an input file to a PDF. This gave me a number of problems, and didn’t seem to support the concept of pages as natively as would be desirable. (It’s still impressive that they managed to get the project to work as well as it does, but it doesn’t produce nice-looking books yet.) After that, I decided that perhaps Firefox’s support for printing would work for me: it works pretty well with many of the CSS printing features, and I can probably script Firefox to output PDFs if I want. Unfortunately, I again ran in to bugs with the rendering. I don’t recall the details at the moment, but I believe that content had a tendency to not wrap between pages in the right spots. Either way, this sent me in search of a high-quality PDF rendering solution.
If you look online for advice about generating PDFs from HTML, you will inevitably run upon many people suggesting PrinceXML (or, as it seems to be rebranding itself, Prince). They’re probably right. It is a commercial piece of software in a case where I had hoped to use free software, but it is still the best solution I have found by far, both in ease of use and functionality.
Prince itself is not cheap. A personal license is $495 at the time of writing, and even that may not cover what I intend to do in terms of converting books automatically. (To be clear, it might be covered, but only just barely if it is. I haven’t asked, for reasons I’ll explain shortly) If you are doing anything serious with Prince, you’re probably looking at a $3800 license per server generating PDFs, or a $1900 one if you’re only doing academic things. Upgrades are available for an additional annual cost. To be clear, if you’re generating revenue from the PDFs (or even just saving yourself loads of time), Prince is almost certainly worth every penny, but it’s prohibitive for side projects.
For non-commercial projects, Prince offers a free version with the requirement that you allow it to add a logo and link to the corner of your document’s first page, link to their website wherever you have Prince PDFs for download, and link to their website on a sponsors/partners page. This is mostly unintrusive (although a tad confusing at first: I’ve considered trying to style in a little “Made with” above the logo to explain why it’s there), and very nice of Prince to allow. (To get the “Non-commercial” license, just download the software: you don’t need a special license key or anything.)
In fact, I had a question about their licensing (“The books are licensed under a Creative Commons license that doesn’t allow me to add restrictions to them, so is it required for people who receive the PDFs from me to keep the Prince logo on them? If so, I can’t use the noncommercial license.”), emailed them, and got an email back quite quickly from Håkon Wium Lie, Prince’s Director (not to mention CTO at Opera and founding member of the Pirate Party of Norway). He’s definitely on top of things, and was quite happy to help. (The answer is no, other people can do whatever they want to the PDFs. In my case, they’re still subject to the Creative Commons license they always were, but that’s not because of Prince.) Later, I had a question about how to get something to render correctly (a somewhat minor, obscure layout bug), and quickly received a comment from Mike Day, the CEO, noting that they were looking into the issue. When I followed up, the bug hadn’t yet been fixed (it undoubtedly has tricky interactions with their page layout code), but I quickly received an alternative suggestion complete with example code. Definitely a pleasant experience all the way around.
If you’re looking for a cheaper option to start with, you’ll probably run into DocRaptor as well. DocRaptor started out as Prince-as-a-service, providing an API to allow people to generate PDFs using Prince. It now appears to support Excel files, although I haven’t looked in to those features. For many people, the benefits of being able to rely on DocRaptor to scale up as your workloads do (they claim “thousands of documents a second”) and the lower initial costs are probably a great benefit. They also provide well-supported libraries for a number of languages, where Prince usage is largely done by command line (although Prince has a PHP API as well). Overall, DocRaptor almost certainly provides benefits for many people. However, their plans aren’t super cheap either, and they’re targeted at recurring use, not one-shot uses like mine. I generated over 2500 PDFs in my final output (one per book, plus one per chapter), which would probably have cost me $149 in a month, assuming I didn’t want to tweak them later. Still far cheaper than the cheapest Prince license, but pricey for a personal side project like mine.
DocRaptor does have a 7-day free trial, which probably would have allowed me to generate whatever I wanted during that time, but that’s not exactly ideal, either. (Nor do I mind paying something for the service, but over a hundred dollars a shot is high for my purposes.) I emailed the DocRaptor folks about a pay-as-you-go plan (so I wasn’t paying monthly fees when I wasn’t using the service), because I had found references to such a plan elsewhere. I got a very nice response from Matt Gordon, the “lead vocalist” for the group running DocRaptor. Unfortunately, they no longer offer that plan, because they found that disproportionately more of their support costs (and they do provide good support) were going to users who didn’t spend much on the service anyway. We had a nice conversation about the possibility of plans that might support alternative uses such as mine, but it doesn’t sound like there’s anything planned in the immediate future. (I can’t blame them, as they need to make money and do what makes sense for their business to continue existing.) They did make a very nice offer (I won’t disclose the details) that I turned down for unrelated reasons, but they’re definitely nice folks too.
My conclusion is that you pretty much can’t go wrong with Prince or DocRaptor. Both have very nice and responsive folks behind them, and seem to be quite well done.
Tables of Contents and Bookmarks
Secondly, I wanted to make sure that chapters and sections were listed in the PDF list of bookmarks. This list is sometimes useful when navigating a book in a PDF viewer, although some viewers don’t show it. Prince again makes this quite easy, simply requiring a CSS annotation for the items you wish to be bookmark headings. (In fact, by default it uses h1-h6 tags, but I disabled that default because it picked up way too many bookmarks.)
In creating the full-book files, I noticed that some books created particularly large files. In general, this appeared to be because they embedded the full source images, rather than resampling them. While an option to resample the images inside Prince would be great, it doesn’t exist at this time. Some of the source images were quite large, and clearly intended to be printed at >= 300 dpi, while most users of the PDFs wouldn’t benefit from such images. My first attempt at reducing file size was to use Ghostscript to resample the images. Ghostscript has some features that work similarly to the now-unavailable Acrobat Distiller, and seemed likely to do the job. Unfortunately, after getting Ghostscript working (Ubuntu 14.04′s version appears to crash on larger documents, but 14.10′s works), I found that it removed page numbering information and bookmarks. The next step was to try to export this metadata using PDFtk before using Ghostscript, and then import it again afterward. Unfortunately, while PDFtk will output page numbering details, it won’t import them into a PDF, and there doesn’t appear to be any easily-available way to do so.
So, I temporarily abandoned the option to resample the images using Ghostscript. (It also may or may not have been worth it in the first place: some Ghostscript-generated files were larger than the Prince originals, so I had to handle both cases.) It may be worth patching Ghostscript in the future to keep the metadata around, but that seems likely to be quite involved. In many cases, you may get some benefit out of using Ghostscript with appropriate options (“gs -q -sDEVICE=pdfwrite -dPDFSETTINGS=/printer -dBATCH -dNOPAUSE -sOutputFile=[outfile] [inputfile]” seems to work well besides the additional metadata), but it was unfortunately unsuitable for my purposes at this time.
Following up on the “whole book PDFs can be pretty big” issue, and after trying to open some such books and experiencing slow loading times, I decided that it may be appropriate to create one PDF per chapter as well as the whole-book PDF. My first pass at creating these PDFs was to use PDFtk to pull out just the pages from a given chapter. This posed a few problems: first, I had to figure out which pages belonged to which chapter. Luckily, the bookmarks inserted by Prince, combined with PDFtk’s metadata output, gave me the starting page for each chapter (although for a few minor reasons, this link was a bit iffy: the generated bookmark title did not always match the section name I had in my database), and I could assume that a chapter ended just before the next one began. Unfortunately, this ran into the same problem I had before: I would lose the page numbering and bookmarks. (Not to mention the fact that I would need to separately render a new first page to describe the licensing and get the Prince logo back on the first page.) Finally, I decided to simply depend on Prince once again.
This solution appears to have worked surprisingly well, with the page numbers matching up where expected. Because the files were rendered separately, there is the possibility of some unforeseen issue (I certainly didn’t inspect the thousands of files by hand), but it seems unlikely.
Finally, when reviewing one of the math textbooks in the collection, I noticed that Prince’s MathML rendering wasn’t particularly great. It is definitely better than nothing, but the rendering quality did leave something to be desired. Unfortunately, the most common web-based solution here, MathJax, doesn’t work very well with Prince. (This is a noted todo item on Prince’s release notes, but it’s not available yet.) After stumbling through a number of other options to try, I ended up using PhantomJS together with MathJax to prerender the math to MathJax’s “HTML-CSS” output (the SVG output didn’t look very good and produced a very large PDF file after the required fixes to make Prince display the SVG output). I forced MathJax to use the STIX fonts (which I installed on my computer), and after the math was rendered, I output the document’s HTML form again (after removing the MathJax wrapper divs). This produced files with reasonably good-looking math, the way they were intended to look. The prerendering code hasn’t been published yet because I haven’t taken the time to clean it up, but if someone is interested, I can definitely post it.
Prerendering with MathJax is a step that seems to have very poor asymptotic time complexity. I haven’t formally benchmarked it, but a chapter’s sections took about two minutes to prerender in total, while the whole chapter itself took roughly twelve minutes to prerender. The whole book took roughly four days to prerender. It’s not clear why this occurred, but the prerendering did eventually succeed. It’s also not clear if this is a bug in MathJax, or simply some inefficiency in PhantomJS, so I have yet to report it as a bug to either project (and may never report it – it’s unlikely to come up in common use).
So, to summarize, getting PDFs of a quality I’m comfortable with took quite a bit of effort. In the end, Prince does most of the work, and I rarely had problems with Prince itself. I think it was worth the effort, at least for a personal learning experience. Hopefully the books will be useful to other people as well. Once again, they’re all available at http://2012books.lardbucket.org. Please feel free to copy or redistribute them as you see fit, pursuant to the terms of the associated Creative Commons by-nc-sa license.
P.S. If you’re interested in any of the print-specific (or Prince-specific) things I did to make the books look decent when printed, it’s all left in the book’s CSS file toward the bottom, under the “prince” @media type. Feel free to reuse any of that styling for any purpose you see fit, in any situation. I do not believe it is covered under the Creative Commons license: you may consider it to be public domain.